Supreme Court Dismisses Plea Challenging Quashing Of FIRs Against Former Mumbai Police Commissioner Sanjay Pandey
Mumbai, 19th November 2026: The Supreme Court has dismissed a petition filed by businessman Sanjay Punamiya challenging the Bombay High Court’s decision to quash two FIRs registered against former Mumbai Police Commissioner Sanjay Pandey and others in 2024 over allegations of extortion, criminal conspiracy, intimidation and fabrication of government documents.
A bench comprising Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh dismissed Punamiya’s special leave petition (SLP) on Tuesday. The court also condoned the delay and granted him permission to file fresh petitions.
Punamiya had filed two separate FIRs accusing Pandey, retired Assistant Commissioner of Police Sardar Patil, Police Inspector Manohar Patil, advocate Shekhar Jagtap, builder Shyamsundar Agrawal and others of criminal conspiracy and extortion.
The Bombay High Court had quashed the FIRs in May 2026, observing that the criminal proceedings initiated at Punamiya’s behest were mala fide and amounted to an abuse of the process of law. The court had also described his complaints as an outcome of a “desperate and vengeful mind” and said they appeared to seek a fishing inquiry into matters that did not warrant an investigation.
Challenging the High Court’s order, Punamiya alleged that Pandey and senior police officers had reopened a 2016 extortion case against him despite its closure. He claimed that police officers threatened to implicate him in fabricated cases unless he gave false statements against then Deputy Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis, then Chief Minister Eknath Shinde and former Mumbai Police Commissioner Param Bir Singh in an alleged Urban Land Ceiling scam.
He also alleged that Agrawal and others used the name of gangster Chhota Shakeel to threaten him into signing a settlement agreement. Further, Punamiya accused Jagtap of forging government appointment letters in 2021 to pose as a special public prosecutor in cases against him, allegedly to prolong his judicial custody.
In his plea before the Supreme Court, Punamiya argued that the Bombay High Court had exceeded its jurisdiction by examining disputed documents and effectively conducting a mini-trial while quashing the FIRs. He also contended that allegations of forgery and criminal conspiracy required investigation.
Appearing for Pandey, advocates Rahul Kamerkar and Mihir Joshi denied his involvement in the allegations and opposed the challenge, arguing that reviving the proceedings would amount to reinstating a case already found by the High Court to be an abuse of the legal process.
